IDNetters Forums

Technical News & Discussion => Mobile Devices News & Discussion => Topic started by: Gary on Dec 03, 2011, 07:58:18

Title: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: Gary on Dec 03, 2011, 07:58:18
It's not just iPhones that have their incendiary moments - some fellow's Samsung Galaxy S II went up in smoke too. In his trouser pocket. I have to wonder if people just take lighters to their phones for publicity sometimes...Its actually a SGS-2 Skyrocket - a recent AT&T model.

http://www.reghardware.com/2011/12/02/samsung_galaxy_s_ii_combusts_in_mans_pocket/
Title: Re: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: Simon on Dec 03, 2011, 09:09:50
I'm beginning to think these are self inflicted too. 
Title: Re: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: Technical Ben on Dec 03, 2011, 13:01:00
I don't know. It's not unreasonable to expect such things to happen. It's like being surprised that matches catch fire.  :whistle:
Title: Re: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: Steve on Dec 03, 2011, 13:07:20
Not sure about that analogy, we know that defective batteries/chargers can pose a fire hazard whilst charging on rare occasions. I expect a match to catch fire when I strike it on most occasions.
Title: Re: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: Gary on Dec 04, 2011, 00:16:56
Quote from: Technical Ben on Dec 03, 2011, 13:01:00
I don't know. It's not unreasonable to expect such things to happen. It's like being surprised that matches catch fire.  :whistle:
That does not really work at all as an analogy. I expect to send a text, not have my phone catch fire although all electrical devices have risks of one kind or another, but that is a rarity when compared with products that behave as expected, but I expect a match to ignite because that is its primary function. Therefore more matches ignite than phones...
Title: Re: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: pctech on Dec 04, 2011, 18:33:03
Maybe the phone was overworked.

Title: Re: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: Technical Ben on Dec 04, 2011, 20:59:49
Quote from: Gary on Dec 04, 2011, 00:16:56
That does not really work at all as an analogy. I expect to send a text, not have my phone catch fire although all electrical devices have risks of one kind or another, but that is a rarity when compared with products that behave as expected, but I expect a match to ignite because that is its primary function. Therefore more matches ignite than phones...

Well, I agree we don't expect them to catch fire. But they are full of dangerous chemicals and packed with potential energy. We would be careful with a box of matches in our pocket (non-safety matches). The same for the phones. A little crack or hole in the plastic casing to the battery, and who knows what will happen?
Title: Re: Now its a Samsung battery to get hot and bothered
Post by: pctech on Dec 04, 2011, 21:05:00
Indeed, just look here http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lithium_ion#Safety_requirements