IDNetters Forums

Technical News & Discussion => Broadband, Internet & General Computer News & Discussion => Topic started by: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:14:45

Title: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:14:45
Sky are changing theres packages across the board, good for people on a budget or not bothered by throttling

Sky bundles broadband in offer and increases broadband speeds

Sky are offering 6 months free up-to 20Meg 'unlimited' broadband in a new promotion open to new and existing Sky customers who take the deal before 31st May. Sky Unlimited usually costs £15 on top of a Sky TV package, or £10 more when taken with the Sky Talk package. Customers have to move their BT line rental to Sky to take advantage of the offer (£11 a month) and either the Sky Talk Freedom (free) or Sky Talk Unlimited calls package (£5 a month). This offer is only available to new Sky customers or existing Sky customers who do not currently have Sky broadband.

Techradar are also reporting that Sky's broadband products are set to change from the 1st of June. All broadband products will be changed to offer up-to 20Meg broadband speeds (dependent on distance from the telephone exchange), even on the ubundled 'Sky Base' which offers free broadband to Sky TV customers, albeit with a low 2GB monthly usage limit. The Sky Unlimited service will also reduce in cost to just £7.50 a month from June 1st to those who take Sky TV and Sky Talk, a reduction of £2.50 a month. It's not clear if people who sign up to offers such as those above will also benefit from this reduced price.

    "Sky is transforming the broadband marketplace again, by providing Britain's best value up to 20Mb truly unlimited broadband service and the UK's only free, up to 20Mb service.

    With these new products, our customers have a very simple choice to make based on how much they use the internet, with peace of mind that they are getting a high quality, reliable service.

    Unlike some other ISPs, Sky promises not to slow down the speed customers enjoy on its network at peak."
    Delia Bushell, (Director of Broadband & Talk) Sky
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 23, 2010, 18:16:32
How on earth did that get past the swear filter? ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:17:45
pure luck.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 23, 2010, 18:20:19
 ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: DorsetBoy on Apr 23, 2010, 18:24:11
It's fine if you want to be stuck forever on their contract.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: quandam on Apr 23, 2010, 18:28:06
Quote from: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:14:45

Unlike some other ISPs, Sky promises not to slow down the speed customers enjoy on its network at peak."
Delia Bushell, (Director of Broadband & Talk) Sky


Do you know if this 'promise' includes their 8Mb Connect package?
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: DorsetBoy on Apr 23, 2010, 18:34:19
Quote from: quandam on Apr 23, 2010, 18:28:06
Do you know if this 'promise' includes their 8Mb Connect package?

Doubt it as that is a BT product, there 24MB package is LLU.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: quandam on Apr 23, 2010, 18:37:02
I would think so!
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:45:04
i know a couple of people on there llu packages and they say its great so suppose a few unlike people, i was one of them.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: quandam on Apr 23, 2010, 18:46:06
Quote from: DorsetBoy on Apr 23, 2010, 18:24:11
It's fine if you want to be stuck forever on their contract.

Looking at the deal and if (a big if in my case) I were able to access their LLU package their contract would not be a great problem for me. I would say, if you are able to get the SKY LLU service at your exchange then the deal they offer has to be given some very, very serious consideration. ;)
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:52:00
It is cracking value for people on a budget or low income.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 23, 2010, 18:54:48
It is, and as long as it works, it's fine.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:56:34
I think there llu is better than the connect package. Must be look at the amount of people on their books.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: DorsetBoy on Apr 23, 2010, 18:57:44
Quote from: Rik on Apr 23, 2010, 18:54:48
It is, and as long as it works, it's fine.

It is said to be a good service with 24/7 phone support, the speeds on LLU are apparently excellent at all times. (Easynet are the ISP )
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 23, 2010, 19:00:32
I just don't fancy leaving IDNet. :)
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Glenn on Apr 23, 2010, 19:25:23
Quote from: DorsetBoy on Apr 23, 2010, 18:57:44(Easynet are the ISP )

Who are owned by Sky http://www.guardian.co.uk/media/2005/oct/21/television.digitalmedia
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: quandam on Apr 23, 2010, 19:27:55
Quote from: DorsetBoy on Apr 23, 2010, 18:57:44
It is said to be a good service with 24/7 phone support, the speeds on LLU are apparently excellent at all times. (Easynet are the ISP )

If it came to my exchange (probably 2 years+ off) I would more than likely make the move, but, the facts are that it isn't, so that is why I am currently with IDNet :thumb:
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: kinmel on Apr 23, 2010, 20:11:28
My son moved onto Sky LLU  2 years ago, he lives within sight of the exchange and gets 22Meg, he has never detected any throttling.

He has had no need to contact their support desk and doesn't use their mail either, so no comment on those aspects.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Den on Apr 23, 2010, 20:37:39
A customer (and friend) lives a few hundred metres closer to the exchange than I do and he is with Sky at the moment. He has had problems with the internal phone system for his business so we rewired it all this week. On asking him about his broadband he said it was very slow. I checked it and found that while I get 6.3mb he is getting 0.1mb  :eek4:  We are leaving it for a few days and then will check again and unless we can get it faster then he will have his line checked and then move to Idnet.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: DorsetBoy on Apr 24, 2010, 06:05:26
Quote from: Den on Apr 23, 2010, 20:37:39
A customer (and friend) lives a few hundred metres closer to the exchange than I do and he is with Sky at the moment. He has had problems with the internal phone system for his business so we rewired it all this week. On asking him about his broadband he said it was very slow. I checked it and found that while I get 6.3mb he is getting 0.1mb  :eek4:  We are leaving it for a few days and then will check again and unless we can get it faster then he will have his line checked and then move to Idnet.

Have you checked to see what package he is on? The free Sky adsl is a 2mb service. Assuming his line is shorter it will more likely be a line/wiring issue,unless of course the router is being switched on and off too frequently. People I know in town are only 60 metres from the exchange and couldn't get the 8mb at all, the synch was all over the place,their PC and router were being switched on and off dozens of times a day as kids/parents came and went, get them to leave the router on 24/7 and problem solved.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Baz on Apr 24, 2010, 08:07:00
Quote from: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:14:45
    "Sky is transforming the broadband marketplace again, by providing Britain's best value up to 20Mb truly unlimited broadband service and the UK's only free, up to 20Mb service.


really??   what does that mean then  :)   :dunno:
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: DorsetBoy on Apr 24, 2010, 08:34:56
Quote from: Baz on Apr 24, 2010, 08:07:00

really??   what does that mean then  :)   :dunno:

Supposedly unlimited/uncapped broadband. ( Note that the Connect 8mb is subject to limilts and traffic shaping AND usage moitoring during peak times) There must be no form of business/commercial use of any kind though,so don't read work emails  ;D.

The T's+C's are here http://www.sky.com/shop/terms-conditions/broadband/  reading down it amuses me that they give all that detail and yet their AUP is not given, if you want to know their AUP terms you have to email them ............ what are they hiding  :dunno:
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 24, 2010, 08:57:37
This is sky remember
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 24, 2010, 09:16:35
So they're trying to hide the Murdochs. ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 24, 2010, 09:18:55
 ;D There are rik, i might give it a try if i had sky at the exchange.
My gran has base on 2mb and says it's fine for saga holidays and ordering from scottish gourmet.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 24, 2010, 09:20:43
What more could a body need...
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: adamr8965 on Apr 24, 2010, 09:21:22
i have no idea im not a oap yet rik  ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 24, 2010, 09:21:43
We can wait.  :evil:
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Technical Ben on Apr 24, 2010, 22:28:59
Quote from: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:14:45
Sky are changing theres packages across the board, good for people on a budget or not bothered by [the internet cutting out during out of office times...]


Sorry for the pessimism. But I;ve been on a "home access" service. It's horrid.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 25, 2010, 01:42:12
O2 have been doing a £7.50 a month unlimited up to 24 Meg ADSL2+ deal for ages although you have to have either a contract or PAYG mobile which is topped up with a tenner or more every three months (price without is £12.50)

Tried it myself but because line is so long it was unstable so moved back to ADSL service.

Unlimited won't stay unlimited for ever, capacity has to be paid for and remember Murdoch is talking about charging for news content on his websites.



Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Gary on Apr 25, 2010, 08:18:58
Quote from: pctech on Apr 25, 2010, 01:42:12
O2 have been doing a £7.50 a month unlimited up to 24 Meg ADSL2+ deal for ages although you have to have either a contract or PAYG mobile which is topped up with a tenner or more every three months (price without is £12.50)

Tried it myself but because line is so long it was unstable so moved back to ADSL service.

Unlimited won't stay unlimited for ever, capacity has to be paid for and remember Murdoch is talking about charging for news content on his websites.




I used the O2 LLU service, it was not bad, but I hated the contract length, when I moved it was alas O2 access, the most awful abomination ever, slow after 6 is an understatement, especially on an 8128 sync. It would crawl below one meg. AS said above unlimited is never truly unlimited forever, and already they are throttling and shaping and doing all they can to make it work, hopefully the LLU side is more robost.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Technical Ben on Apr 25, 2010, 13:33:52
Well, "unlimited" could be, within reason. If there was one cable to every person, then it could run at full sync continuously. But as it's all shared down central connections, it's not possible. They should be honest. You can say "as much as you can eat for £7.50" because you know no one has a stomach as large as a hippo, or greater than the size of the supply of food. However, you cannot say "as much downloads as you want for £7.50" when you know that not all of your customers can even log on to the internet at the same time, let alone get a service.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 25, 2010, 15:16:07
The unlimited thing works on the principle that the vast majority will not heavily load their connections and thus the network 24/7 so to them it is unlimited.

The problem comes from the bandwidth hogs who run peer to peer with the transfer rate at max while watching iPlayer, Youtube or whatever.

This slows down not only the access circuits but the core links within an ISPs network.

One of the first things you are taught when doing the CCNA as I am is that network usage has to be properly managed otherwise the network will grind to a halt because the roiuters, switches and other equipment becomes overwhelemed and traffic gets dropped.

I do agree that unlimited shouldn't be used though but the problem is, the bandwidth hogs that fall foul of the fair usage policies have little or no technical understanding of the effects of their actions (and probably don't care)

so I can see it from both sides but I do back the actions of some ISPs that have booted users or hobbled their service,

Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pdu on Apr 25, 2010, 17:28:02
Carrier routers can handle immense quantities of traffic without issue: http://www.cisco.com/en/US/products/ps5763/prod_models_comparison.html - the limits placed on connections are largely down to the insane cost of rolling out new cabling in the UK, mostly local taxes.  3 years ago a friend of mine in Germany laughed her socks off that we had bandwidth caps in this country as we fetched a movie to watch on her alicedsl 16mbit connection at 8pm without any problems whatsoever, I can see why they do it in the US, it's a massive country and rolling out more fibre to IXP and transit locations can be massively expensive, but we're a tiny island, if the Gov't eased up on their greed for digging up pavements, we could (and should) have one of the most impressive national networks on the planet.  Incidentally, under Thatcher, BT had cash to spare and approached the Gov't asking if they could begin their fibre upgrade to plan for the future, unfortunately they were told no, and the cash was diverted elsewhere.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 25, 2010, 20:27:38
Very true yes but does depend on whether this or lower end kit is being used.

Also it does depend on how much a tier 1 provider want to charge per connection or for a trunked connection (I am endeavouring to find price lists for the likes of Level 3, Cogent, Sprint and the like)

Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Technical Ben on Apr 25, 2010, 21:53:21
Like I said. If the system/equipment cannot handle it, don't offer it.
It's like saying "all you can eat" and then taking the second plate off someone for the "cheek" of eating more than one plate...
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: DorsetBoy on Apr 26, 2010, 08:43:48
http://www.trustedreviews.com/networking/news/2010/04/26/Sky-Upping-All-Broadband-Connections-to-20Mbit/p1

QuoteVirgin Media's cable broadband may be running away with the UK speed crown, but Sky could well be the new DSL champ. Murdock's minions have announced it will soon provide all subscribers with a free upgrade to a 20Mbit service. Catches? Actually, not many.

From 1 June Sky will simplify its broadband services with two primary packages: 'Sky Unlimited' and 'Sky Everyday Lite'. The former will cost £7.50pm for Sky TV customers with Sky Talk or £12.50pm for those without and will have no traffic shaping and no fair use policy.

In Sky's own words: "It comes with no usage caps, fair use policies or traffic management, making it ideal for those who want the freedom to download emails, photos, TV programmes, movies and games. It's also ideal for those who want to access live and on-demand TV through Sky Player." Yep, good stuff.

This'll ruffle a few ISP's feathers ....
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Glenn on Apr 26, 2010, 08:48:55
It won't happen, there are  lot of exchanges where either they have no equipment installed, or the exchanges have not  upgraded to ADSL2+
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 26, 2010, 08:51:20
But what great hype along the way... ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Gary on Apr 26, 2010, 09:19:48
Companies could hang fibre from the telegraph poles, I think Virgin are trialling this, why BT have not thought of that  ::) but once again small exchanges like ours with very little in the way of financial gain will get nothing.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Technical Ben on Apr 26, 2010, 10:24:51
"it will soon provide all subscribers with a free upgrade to a 20Mbit service."
There you go. A lie. Will they install ASDL2+ for me? No, so I will not get a "free upgrade to *20Mbit service"!
That's it. How about I offer to now give the entire country a free upgrade to *2billionbit connection?
/leaves thread





*up to, no garuntees
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 26, 2010, 10:29:22
You mean you don't trust a promise from Sky, Ben? I can't think why.  :whistle:
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pdu on Apr 26, 2010, 12:06:22
PCTech: as for pricing of bandwidth from upstream providers at the carrier level, I can tell you off the top of my head that hurricane electric does pricing for $1/mbit as long as you buy a minimum of a 1gbit link, that's full commit uncontended and unshared and obviously you have to meet them in a DC where they operate, many of the usual London centres are where they operate.  Also it's worth remembering the likes of linx, lonap, amx which are seriously cheap IXPs where you can pickup 10gbit link for not much over £1k/month.  I can't actually remember the pricing from L3/Cogent/Sprint etc.. but it shouldn't be too much more than HE are charging.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 26, 2010, 13:28:35
Interesting info but I think a lot of ISPs (particularly the large consumer ones) are cheapskates in that regard and will max out a relatively low bandwidth link such as a Fast Ethernet link rather than invest in Gigabit links which are required when people are making heavy use of services that don't make use of multicast.

As others have also said the problem may also lay with the links from the exchange, its all a matter of how it is used.

Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pdu on Apr 26, 2010, 17:29:54
I love the fact that if you push in excess of 80% of your links traffic with lynx consistently, they bill you a port overuse charge equal to the cost of another port, if more upstream providers did this then we wouldn't see cheapskate ISPs trying to get by with insufficient bandwidth for their customers :)  It's not as if the connections are fully utilised with the asymmetric nature of home broadband anyway, hence most ISPs that operate their own infrastructure also have side brands doing server hosting and colo.  You'd think charging twice for bandwidth they'd splash out and get a bit more wouldn't you lol
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 09:28:13
Yes indeed

As an academic exercise I did look into the costs of setting up my own ISP but stopped after seeing the costs of the BT centrals whiich were stupid thousand pound a month each.


Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 27, 2010, 09:33:49
Not to mention the installation costs.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 09:55:17
Yes, plus routers, rack space and then of course the external connections.

Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 27, 2010, 10:00:22
Not to be undertaken lightly, eh. ;)
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 10:09:33
definitely not and you need rather a large bank balance (or bank loan) to get off the ground.

Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 27, 2010, 10:11:21
You would, and it would be some time before you reached break even, let alone profit.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 10:23:27
indeed but if I had the resources I would take up the challenge as I reckon I could create a decent service.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 27, 2010, 10:31:55
I can lend you a fiver. )
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 10:41:10
 ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Gary on Apr 27, 2010, 12:24:47
But could you come up with a pricing stricture like AAISP
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 12:31:38
AAISP are ridiculously expensive compared to others so I'd be hoping to give people better value.

Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Rik on Apr 27, 2010, 12:32:28
Quote from: Gary on Apr 27, 2010, 12:24:47
But could you come up with a pricing stricture like AAISP

You mean confusing? ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 12:35:30
Messrs Andrews and Arnold must be raking it in.

Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Glenn on Apr 27, 2010, 12:41:00
My friend in Telford has has a result. He got home yesterday, outside his front door was a package, a BT home hub v2 (he's with BT). He replaced his current router, which had a 2mb connection. He now connects at 6mb! His exchange does not have ADSL2+ according to Sam.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 12:44:43
not been able to bring him back from the Dark Side, eh Glenn?
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Glenn on Apr 27, 2010, 13:24:55
No, I've tried.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pctech on Apr 27, 2010, 14:53:26
The Force must be weak with him then  ;D
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: Glenn on Apr 27, 2010, 15:13:32
His pockets are too deep, and arms too short at the moment.
Title: Re: Sky offers good value broadband.
Post by: pup on May 08, 2010, 14:43:07
Quote from: adamr8965 on Apr 23, 2010, 18:14:45
The Sky Unlimited service will also reduce in cost to just £7.50 a month from June 1st to those who take Sky TV and Sky Talk, a reduction of £2.50 a month.

But if you are on sky's middle "everyday" package, you will either lose bandwidth (10Gb to 2Gb) or get an price increase for a unwanted bandwidth increase.